Отзывы Whiskybase
учтено 117 заметок · текстовых 87 · полный lossless-снимок WB (полнота подтверждена)
Суммаризация отзывов
Мощный, дымно-хересовый Talisker с морскими, перечными и йодистыми нотами, высокий градус интегрирован на удивление мягко, финиш очень долгий. Мнения расходятся: от «одного из лучших виски» до критики за сернистость, резину и завышенную цену.
развернуть подробно
В большинстве отзывов виски описывают как мощный, «брутальный» и сильно шерри-выраженный: хересовая бочка даёт густую сладость, сухофрукты, шоколад, кожу и специи, а Talisker сохраняет дым, торф, морскую соль, йод и перец. Крепость около 62% неоднократно называют удивительно хорошо интегрированной, почти не ощущаемой; нос и вкус — многослойными и сложными, финиш — исключительно долгим. Часть дегустаторов считает его лучшим или одним из лучших розливов Talisker и вообще виски, отмечая сложность и баланс; есть сравнения с Talisker 25 лет 2001 года — оба на высочайшем уровне, при этом этот розлив описывают как более фруктовый, а 25-летний как более хересовый, древесный и пряный, без явного победителя.
Вместе с тем есть заметные критические и противоречивые мнения. Несколько человек упоминают серу — от «не мешает» и «даже хорошо» до неприятного оттенка, уходящего при проветривании; звучат жалобы на «медицинский» оттенок, резину и сгоревшие спички, «грязный» профиль, сухую горечь в финише и прямо заявленное разочарование из-за неприятия сочетания хереса с торфом; один отзыв называет рейтинг завышенным и говорит, что небольшого сэмпла достаточно. Отмечают, что херес может «забивать» типичные талискеровские маркеры, а перца может не быть; один отзыв называет виски менее сложным, чем другие старые релизы. Вода оценивается по-разному: кому-то раскрывает ароматы, при избытке «сплющивает», а по одному мнению — «предаёт». Цена в 1400–1900 € названа неоправданной при общей высокой оценке самого виски.
собрано 87/117 текстовых отзывов · полный lossless-снимок WB
· 2026-10-20T04:04:05Z · источник evidence
compared with the 85's laga 21 and brora 30 MMA champion ship. I think even the 01's 25yo is better. It is good but for me it lacks a bit complex. Pure sherry and sweet
нос 92 · вкус 91 · финиш 93
нос 88 · вкус 89 · финиш 89
нос 92 · вкус 91 · финиш 92
нос 97 · вкус 96 · финиш 96
Of nearly 1000 malts tasted, the mMn is the best so far!
нос 95 · вкус 98 · финиш 98
нос 96 · вкус 95 · финиш 94
I opened this bottle on a very special day for me because someone said "Miss this and your life will be incomplete". At 62%, it definitely stings the nostrils. Not very subtle. Very peppery, very meaty, very syrupy, very powerful, and of course quite peaty. Lots of cherry cough drops. Some sulfur but no where close to egregious. Finish is very long. This is a brutally powerful whisky that attacks all the senses. 92-93 points. My first born baby girl was born that day. Memories.
Water is its best friend, as time and air would be too long for this one. Funny enough, the perfume seems to be dominant in the first half-hour, it's like floral perfume, with scents of daffodil and lavender. Downgraded from 95 in 2021 to 92 in 2023. Just doesn't impress me the same way it did before.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
91 |
Floral notes are profound, carried with dried hay, soft musky peat, and toasted brown bread. Wait a while and don't stick your nose in it, that's where the fire starts and jitters up the nose. Hot green Sichuan peppercorn, lapsang souchong tea, salted paprika, blood orange, lime peel, cumin seeds. |
| Вкус |
93 |
Melted cream cheese, creme brulee, nutmeg cake, hazelnut chocolate of 40 - 60 % darkness. Water brings out orange, ripen, and heavy citrus. It's a bomb of fruit notes - orange again, pear, cantaloupe, candied ginger, onion cooked in butter and drizzled with seawater. Malted sweetness prevails, where chocolate, sweet caramel, reduced brown sugar, toasted pecans, chocolate chip cookies, and all thing sweet, thick, and dense; Like molasses or treacle but with the added complexity. Sherry does not show up like other sherried whiskies but rather creeps up in the form of more complex notes. Rich earth notes are evident too, mostly towards the back hitting on the finish. It's like drinking sparkling water from a heavily mineralized water source, both dry and gritty. |
| Финиш |
92 |
Spicy of course, warm peat, sweet chocolate, licorice, black bread, cardamom seeds, ash, dried persimmons, roasted lamb chops with rosemary. Sulfur is good here, could do more but it might kill off the sweet lighter notes. |
Nose- Bath in the fruit sea, salty cherry compote, smoked oranges, a lot of minerals, there is old leather, tobacco, but also milk chocolate and oysters, after a long moment, scalded hay Taste - smoked cherries, a lot of bitter cocoa, a little moldy, light sulfur, salty sea water, spicy chilli pralines, and a little rosemary, Finish - very long, warm with tannins, then milk chocolate with ripe oranges, coffee, chilli claw, smoked paprika. The brine with melted chocolate stays for a long time, Summing up a great interesting waist and here, depending on your preferences, it can be 92 or maybe 95, I get 94.
нос 93 · вкус 94 · финиш 93
The fragrant nose, while subtle, gives way to a massive palate full of signature pepper, and a next level drying fruitiness - fresh ripe strawberries - which carries into what is perhaps the longest and most full flavoured finish ever. Check out my review on YouTube!
The fiercest of all Talisker out there. Pure heat and pepper balanced by mindboggling sherry.
нос 91 · вкус 92 · финиш 92
Salty, mineral, beautifully fruity - Very large.
93/100 given by Serge of whiskyfun.com
Very interesting experience - of course much different than the common Talisker profile. Heavy sherry wood, balanced sweetness, nice fruitiness. Great!
The 89P are meant quite well for the sulfur grades, I'm rather insensitive anyway, I am a mystery to the ratings with so many participants here, sometimes you even read sulfur in the notes? In the mouth it makes up for some.
I am Happy to finally make my own opinion about this famous bottling. And it is indeed interesting to discuss about!!
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
93 |
Intense, sherry with peat, sea, salt and fruits as expected but similiar to many others and not as good as e.g. some old ardbegs. |
| Вкус |
93 |
Was a little bit too punchy but few drops of water is a good choice here. Very intense sherry bomb with easy to recognize talisker smoke and sea breeze. Very exciting!! |
| Финиш |
97 |
Absolutely amazing!!! What a power with maintaining all layers and flavours. Punchy, spucy, very long, intense, perfect!!! |
Notes from a sample With water: Significantly sweeter on the nose, now with a little tea, creamier and more sherry-accentuated in the mouth, slightly more white pepper in the finish. A great and intense malt, whose potential with water I can only guess at the moment
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
93 |
Campfire smoke, black pepper, cooling alcohol, sherry, old rotten wood, slightly sour |
| Вкус |
94 |
heavy, at first sweet start, with apricot and cherry, salt and a lot of pepper |
| Финиш |
93 |
metallic, cute, seaweed |
N smoke, charcoal, leather, seaweed, campfire, berries, a little sulphur, the aroma seems to dissipate after a long time 92 T is strong and full-bodied in the mouth, berry, leather, syrup, smoke is persistent, alcohol is strong but not strong, bacon starts in the middle, and the syrup is always there F is long, smoky and a little sweet, and I drink it for half a year. The taste is almost not broken. I even think it tastes better than when the bottle was first opened. It is indeed very strong.
нос 93 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
94 |
|
| Вкус |
95 |
Absolutely stunning dram and one of the best Talisker I ever had (and I had a few). Tasted it aside the Lagavulin 21yo 1985-2007, which is also a great whisky. Usually I prefer Lagavulin, this time Talisker is the clear winner…on a insanely high level of course. |
| Финиш |
94 |
|
In fact, I would prefer the Bourbon 20 from 1982-2003. Of course, it is undeniable that this Shirley 20 is more complex and grand. Both are the pinnacle of Tescar products.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
93 |
The first thing to say is that it is very durable, so you don't have to worry about drinking it quickly. I drank 4 times with different corkscrew times in different scenes. The longest cork is nearly a year old, but I still feel very online. At the same time, enough sobering can get rid of the uncomfortable sulfur smell, but even more Good; very good sherry flavor presentation, very light peat smoke, some moist earth, then all complex fruit and floral, very sure smells great floral. |
| Вкус |
92 |
Very strong, very strong, not only the strong feeling brought by the alcohol, but the support of the wine itself is very good. On the contrary, the 62% alcohol does not feel uncomfortable to me. I did not choose to add water; sea water, citrus, licorice, Leather, very rich flavor, but also well balanced. |
| Финиш |
93 |
Chocolate, licorice, honey, then sea water, peat and some earth, the finish is very charming, very strong and persistent, and the flavor is still very good, like you have been drinking it. |
An excellent peaty sherry, complex, tasty, very drinkable despite the ABV. But the Talisker markers are a bit crushed by the sherry cask. I so far rated it higher but tastes change ;)
Perfectly integrated sherry. Doesn't need water.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
94 |
|
| Вкус |
94 |
IT: 94 B: 93 |
| Финиш |
92 |
|
http://kaypingers-whiskyblog.de/frontend/fullarticle.php?id=183 Color: Full gold / old gold Nose: Pepper, pepper and more pepper - dull, highly explosive aromas carried by black powder, fuse, smoky leather, honey-rich cereal with fruity, over-ripe yellow mirabelle plums and leather in all possible variations. But there are also aromas of tropical fruits such as mango, papaya and sweet golden kiwi in the nose. Taste: Tingling, full power on the tongue! Season until it stops - a heavy load of salt combined with tons of black pepper. In addition a lot of sherry and delicately emerging oak with elegantly integrated, tart herbs. Madness! Finish: Very long with a combination of nose and taste: wood, herbs, sherry, orange peel, leather, fuse, black powder and again the oversized peppery spice that seems to stick to the palate. 94 points (nose: 93 / taste: 95 / finish: 93)
[February, 2018] After a series of old and expensive whiskies that were rather disgusting (either soapy/perfumy or spoiled by sulphur) I really need an excellent dram tonight. So I selected this one and I think the chance of being disappointed here is close to zero. I bought bottle no. 3995 for 107 Euro in November, 2002 (hence the price score). The colour is russetmuscat and the texture shows a great oiliness of many small tears that stick to the top of the glass and consolidate to a fat sticky ring that does not move at all. Very late some bigger tears appear that do not build legs. This promises an excellent mouthfeel and very long finish! The nose is quite impressive on a fine spicy-herbal sherry profile with dozens of different aromas in a firm, appropriate wooden setting. Despite the 62% abv it is not punchy at all. The dram arrives hot on the palate (remember: 62% abv) and it immediately covers the whole of the mouth with a warming feeling, simply excellent. One of the best mouthfeels I had for a long time and not a single minor distracting moment (like bitter, drying or adstringent notes). The taste is multi-layered around this superb sherry profile with all the sherry-induced flavours one can dream of. It is supplemented by a delicious spicy wooden framework and a couple of sweet barley sugars (different ones, I swear!). Again not a single flaw that I can find. The finish is very long and spicier than the taste with some minor bitter notes (tannins) at the very end that are rather welcomed (as a counterpart to the sweet sherry flavours) than distracting. Some water releases even more aromas in the nose and it turns the taste and finish sweeter. But be careful not to add too much water as the dram flattens quickly below around 48% abv. Actually I like it best when reduced to about 50% abv. As expected, the chance of being disappointed by this dram is not close to but it is zero! Another proof that most probably the best age for single malt whiskies is around 20 years (there are exceptions above and below, of course...)!
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
Fantastic!
нос 95 · вкус 94 · финиш 93
нос 95 · вкус 93 · финиш 94
One of the most complex whiskys I've ever had in a glass. It should be particularly emphasized that the spectrum of flavors is equally varied and powerful in all areas (nose / mouth / finish). 62% are of course an announcement, but are also necessary to bring this cargo of flavors over.
The best Talisker and the best whisky I've ever had in a glass
Best sherried Scotch whisky 1936 vintage onwards, 75 whiskies tasted. This whisky was 26th ,out of 75 Whisky Heaven 96 points average. 1) Glen Cawdor 1964/1983 43%Duthies for Samaroli 95/96/96 - 96 Gold Medal Drams 95 Points average 2) Caperdonich 1966 32 year cask 134 53.1% Signatory 95/95/95 - 95 3) Glen Avon 1974 sherry cask 59.9% G&M 94/95/95 - 95 4) Inchgower 1975 25 year 49.7% cask 9176 Kingsbury 94/95/95 - 95 5) Strathisla 1967/1986 57% Duthies for Samaroli 94/95/95- 95 6) Glengoyne 1972 40 year 55.5% Mos 1244 Diamonds 96/95/94 - 95 7) Inchgower 1965 39 year cask 5423 48.1% Jack Wiebers 95/94/95 – 95 *8) Macallan 1952 15 year 80 proof Rinaldi Import* 85/96/94 – 92 But 95 for palate & finish average. Note The Macallan 1952 probably would have come 2nd if the nose had scored similar to the palate and finish, it would be unfair to push it any further down the pecking order and it was, along with the Glen Cawdor 1964 the only whisky I gave a 96p for the palate. It is where it is because the nose let it down and had a burnt off note I did not like but the taste was lovely. Silver Medal Drams 94 Points average 9) Tobermory 1972 23 year 50% MI De Viris Illlustribus 94/95/94 - 94 10) Glenfarclas 105 40 year 60%OB 94/95/94 – 94 11) Glen Mhor 30 year Bar Metro 60.1% 94/95/94 – 94 12) Dallas Dhu 1982 24 year cask 3739 OB 93/95/94 - 94 13) Springbank 35 year 46% Millenium OB 93/95/94 - 94 14) Macallan 1939 70 proof GM OB 93/95/94 - 94 15) Glenglassaugh 1972 38 year cask 2891 59.1% ob 94/94/95 - 94 19247 16) Tobermory 1972 OB purple label 32 year 49.5% 94/95/93 – 94 17) Longmorn 1968 SMWS 7.27 53.8% 93/94/95 - 94 18) Aberfeldy 19yr manager’s dram 1991 61.3% 94/94/94 - 94 19) Balblair 1966 38 year 44% ob 94/94/94 - 94 20) Speyburn 1975 cask 3413 55.4%OB 94/94/94 - 94 41085 21) Glen Avon 15 year 57% Avonside whisky 93/94/94 – 94 22) Glen Grant 1964 50 year cask 4462 gm 93/94/94 - 94 23) Glenlossie 1972 17 year 57.7% Sestante 93/94/94 – 94 24) Tamnavulin 35 year Forrester cask 3087 52.6% OB 93/94/94 - 94 25) Blair Athol 21 year moon import the cars 93/94/94 - 94 *26) Talisker 1981 20 year 62% 93/94/94 - 94 27 )Longmorn 1972 33 year laird bottling 43.7% 93/94/94 -94 28) Mortlach 14 year 57% sestante 95/93/94 - 94 Bronze Medal Drams 93 Points average 29) Balmenach 14 year 1971 57.5% ob sestante 93/94/93 - 93 30) Glenugie 1967 59.5% sherry wood Sestante 92/94/93 - 93 31) Talisker 1957 57% GM black label 92/93/94 - 93 32) Glenfarclas 21 year unblended 51.5% Edward Giaccone 93/94/92 – 93 33) Jura 1966 30 year 51.6% cask 1868 Signatory 92/93/94 - 93 34) springbank 1966 58.1% cask 443 LB 95/93/92 - 93 35) Highland Park 1973 34 year OB cask 6384 46.5% 92/93/93 - 93 36) Tamdhu 1962 44 year 43% GM 92/93/93 - 93 37) Millburn 1967 34 year omc 50% 93/92/94 - 93 38) Laphroaig 1998 20 year cask 700296 54.6 WM 94/92/93 93 39) Glenrothes 1947 28 year 43% ferrarato OB 94/93/91- 93 40) Strathisla 1963 48 year 51.8% cask 576 GM 94/92/92 – 93 92 points average 41) Talisker 1955 50 year Secret Stills GM 91/93/92 - 92 42) Bunna 1968 34 year 43.5% OB 93/93/91 – 92 43) Glengoyne 1969/98 cask 3525 51.6% OB 93/93/91 - 92 44) Glenlochy 1965 32 year cask 1528 47.9% 92/92/93 - 92 45) Tomintoul 1966 44 year cask 5261 49.1% JW 93/92/92 - 92 46) Caperdonich 1972 39 year cask 52.8% TWA 91/92/93 - 92 47) Pride of Strathspey 1939 43 year gm (Macallan) 95/92/90 - 92 48) Macallan 1958/59 25 year Anniversary OB 94/92/91 - 92 49) Glenlossie 1938 43 years 40% GM 93/92/91 - 92 50) Glenrothes 1966 36 year 51.8% cask 1438 OB 94/91/91 – 92 51) Avonside 1938 39 year 43% (Glenlivet) GM 94/92/90 - 92 91 points average 52) Miltonduff 1966 22 year Pluscarden Valley 58.4% 88/93/93 - 91 53) Avonside 1938 33 year 43% (Glenlivet) GM 89/93/92 - 91 54) Glendronach 1972 cask 706 43 year 51.1% 90/92/92 – 91 55) Glenfarclas 1964 40 year NC 1578 Recheirich 91/92/91 - 91 56) Strathisla Decanter, Milton Distillery, William Longmire 90/92/91 - 91 (Very rare whisky, early 1950`s peated Strathisla) 57) Longmorn 1972 37 year 51.3% TWA 92/91/91 -91 58) Highland Park 1960 dumpy 17 year 43% OB Ferraretto 92/91/90 - 91 59) Glenrothes 1972 29 year Restricted Release 43% OB 90/91/91 - 91 60) Aberlour 1964 25 year 43% OB 93/90/91 – 91 61) Bowmore 1956 43% OB, pure islay malt seagull label 94/90/88 – 91 62) Macphail’s 1938 Dram Taker’s 40% GM 92/92/89 – 91 63) Bowmore 1970 34 year cask 4689 56.6% 92/91/89 – 91 90 points average 64) Old Speyside 1966 40 year 45.6% Taste Still 87/92/91 - 90 65) Strathisla 1937 37 year 40% 70 proof GM 90/91/89 – 90 66) Highland Park dumpy 19 year 43% OB Ferraretto Imp 91/90/89 – 90 67) Benriach 1984 28 year 50.2% cask 1050 OB 89/89/91 - 90 89 points average & under 68) Auchentoshan 1970 21 year 43% ob, sherry 93/87/88 - 89 69) Longmorn 1972 39 year 45% LMDW 93/88/87 - 89 70) Macallan 1962 25 year anniversary OB 43% 89/88/88 - 88 71) Glen Grant 1936 decanter 50 year gm 85/89/88 - 87 72) Ben Nevis 1967 41 year, cask 1281 49.4% 87/85/91 – 87 73) Glen Grant 1953 58 year 47.9% GM 85/83/82 – 83 74) Glenlossie 1975 44 year cask 2907 GM 86/65/70 – 73 Tried right at the end Bonus Dram Daftmill cask 029/2009 sherry 61.1% 91-92 points average
I tried this whisky for the second time today. This time in a Talisker tasting with some older bottlings and directly in parallel with the Talisker 25y from 2001 (first edition). Both whiskys convince with their sherry intensity! You could almost think it was the same barrel, only that the 20y has more fruitiness here and the 25y has a little more wood and minimal spice due to its 5 years more. In any case, both whiskys are top quality and are a lot of fun!
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
91 |
|
| Вкус |
89 |
Sulphur |
| Финиш |
90 |
|
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
Disillusioned. I'm not a big fan of the sherry-peat combi here, but you may say there's "balance" between the distillate and cask.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
88 |
In comparison to the 1955 Cask 1315 this one was much smokier, and the cask influence came in a less pleasant way. A much elusive opening with chalks, rubber tires, and coal smoke, underneath which came the touches of hay, horse stable, and copper coins, while aeration helped opening up to show cloves, star anise, liquorice, dried lemon, Seville orange and glazing sugar. It’s much more vibrant and energetic for sure, while the accompany of chocolate, prunes and hints of floral notes enhanced the complexity of the nose. Humus and cured meat, even with a sprinkle of cumin. Still it was too murky and dirty in my book. |
| Вкус |
89 |
Even bigger and bolder thanks to the ABV, with insane sweetness of fudge and peppery attack at the beginning. Oily texture and superb body. Now more crystalline fruit drops, lemon and orange, while the rubbery tires, spent matches remained unchanged and became even dominating as time passed. Exhale to find light chocolates and some very discreet waxiness from Pledge and nectarine |
| Финиш |
89 |
Heavyweight finish for sure. A dry palate but not without profound sweetness of treacle at the back, also some dried oranges and dried flowers. Now the bonfire became more apparent with smoke coming out. Fresh sashimi drizzled with sea water, extremely vibrant maritime notes, but ended up in dry bitterness. |
Aroma:Intense;Palate:93/100; Aftertaste:Long.
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 93
нос 91 · вкус 92 · финиш 92
Would be the best Whisky (Talisker No.44) ever, if the Price wouldn´t be that high. Maybe it depend on each other;-) Fantastic Nose, great Body, best Finish of all tasted Whiskys so far. This is one of the most sophisticated Whiskys I ever tasted. Great Job, Talisker! Talisker No.44
нос 95 · вкус 96 · финиш 97
I understand now why it was one of the best Talisker bottling. The rich distillery character finally found the perfect wood, the perfect sherry and perfect maturing time. Awesome!
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
93 |
Very rich and complex: matured sherry, spicy oak and fruits: banana, mango, prune and cherry. Coffee, chocolate, Bagarol shoe polish, rubber, herbals, seaweed. But well come over the sea salty, peppery, peaty Talisker character as well. If it's much contact with the air goes to Port Ellen complexity. |
| Вкус |
94 |
Extremely powerful, but the 62% is absolutely not exorbitant! Honey sweet sherry, peat, huge oak, citruses and leather perfect wedding with the salty, peppery Talisker character, which richly presents itself! Ash, smoke, phosphorus and sulfur. The whole with very grotesque, but nearly perfect full range! |
| Финиш |
93 |
Long, perfect woody flavors and ash remains in the end |
Too sulphury and too medical to my liking, sorry guys
Eyes: Golden Scent Nose: Condensed and slender smoke, some shoe polish and leather goods, then cream, then mixed banana mash, durian crisp, pineapple sauce, and some incense at the end, smelling Not unrestrained, with some oxidized grease. Taste Palate: high saltiness, slightly sweet, no acid. Powerful smoky, active yellow fruits (jackfruit, pineapple), buttery wood strips, the bitterness of grapefruit, some salt and smoked bacon at the end. Final rhyme Finish: long, slightly salty, slightly smoked, black tea soup, light pineapple cake, fresh milk mousse Body: heavy and full of fat, strong and smooth, no tannins Nose: 89/100 Palate: 90/100 Finish: 92/100 Body: 95/100 Overall: 91.5/100, the wine is strong, but the burning sensation is not strong, like a mouthful of grape seed oil.
re taste for a h2h after i scored the Glen Avon 1974 95 points wb id 67413. Yeah i am still happy with a 93-94 score which is with water but i will settle on 94 as the Glen Avon was a touch better.
нос 94 · вкус 94 · финиш 93
Today in the Talisker Vertical, there is plenty of food against the Talisker 25 - 2001. Both at an extremely high level! This 20y - 62% offers more fruity aromas, in the direction of blackberries and the 25y - 2001 is a sherry bomber with a little more wood and spice. We had at least 4cl each. We couldn't make out a winner. Both whiskys are on top level!
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
Very intense and powerful Talisker, where the sherry cask comes through noticeably. That makes it very interesting, as does the slightly dirty, maritime influence (meant in a positive way, as it is very fitting and harmonious). Exciting and really tasty at the same time. Top.
нос 93 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
State of the art peaty/sherry, la touche Talisker en prime.
Beeswax nose, encaustic, light black pepper, pineapple. The alcohol is perfectly integrated, the smoke of fire of wood (chimney), the precious wood and the orange. In the mouth the alcohol is incredibly integrated, it is difficult to believe that it is 62 °. The attack is sweet, Talisker pepper is present without being nag, always orange, a veil of turpentine. What is especially striking is its extreme drinkability. In the end, the pepper disappears and the smoke settles in its place without violence, with this orange always in the background. A very delicate dram, a very beautiful expression of the distillery, a real crush.
Bottle # 1667 sold empty at ebay.
N- Lovely red hue. Complex with a lot going on, initial impression of sulphury, husky baked malt, cereal cookie and ashy with mineral, then toasted wheat bread with dried fruit raisins jam, underlay with perfum-y nail polish. Evolved effortlessly to minted butter, lightly soaked brandied raisin, whiff of leather. Prominent minty notes probably only sign of the high strength here, gracefully soft despite at 62%. Fresh ginger bread with salts emerged with hint of oxidized sherry. P- Bold and masculine, firm coat of waxy boiled dried fruit with restrained sweetness, lush of ashy charred wood on the retro-hale. F- Long, delicious, togarashi mix with lasting ashed umami spiciness. Would be perfect if with a pinch of bitter-ish sea-salt...
нос 95 · вкус 93 · финиш 90
Trying this at about 50% and comparing it to the 45% 1955 50 year Secret Stills G&M it is difficult to pick a winner. The Secret Stills is more succulent, and full bodied yet compared to this it is more one dimensional, probably because the 1981 has the peat/pepper/sherry combo in perfect harmony but both are outstanding malts in their own right of course. So difficult what is better the vivacity of the 1981 or the elegance of the 1955, I cannot decide so this is down one point to 94 and I was going to award the Secret Stills equal but as there is no distinguishable Talsiker note, 93 is fair.
N95 P96 F95
нос 95 · вкус 96 · финиш 95
нос 95 · вкус 94 · финиш 94
First, gunpowder, oily but non-invasive peat, smoked, leather. Then it's the sherry that is fully expressed with chocolate, black fruits and nuts, coated in the above. After a long aeration in the glass, almost 2 hours, I find a mineral and iodized side to it which hardly appeared until then. In the end, it is an astonishing fruitiness that takes up the most space. Really beautiful and yet I'm not the biggest fan of peat
Drinking Date: 20/10/2024
нос 91 · вкус 92 · финиш 92
нос 93 · вкус 92 · финиш 92
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
95 |
Impressive nose, ultra multilayered, ultra complex and greedy. Super fresh, with strong mint, savory, old leather, dark chocolate around 80%, orangette, candy sugar, Chokotoff or Michoko if you're French, burnt cask, hospital corridor, cardamom, light peat. |
| Вкус |
94 |
Beautiful round, delicate, silky and oily texture, with a crazy alcohol integration I'm still looking for the 62%, gingerbread, mint, caramel, orange, dried herbs, many others notes, but it's so melted and integrated that's quite hard to decipher it. Just stunning ! |
| Финиш |
95 |
Maybe one of the longest finish I get with a whisky, that's really impressive, that's not only ultra sticky, but absolutely expressive and supra deep. A full of bath of refine and delicate caramel with black pepper, star anise, peat, ultra reduced and ultra cooked peach, apricot and mango stuck to the bottom of the pan, cardamom and spices in quantity, leather and dried herbs. What a complexity and deepness !!! |
нос 92 · вкус 91 · финиш 90
nice Talisker!
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
Power in the nose and power on the palate, all what you loves at Talisker is united here. Jim Murray says: Miss this and your life will be incomplete, i agree.
After last nights Port Ellen peat fest I thought I would continue the theme with some peated sherry monsters as follows in a mini H2H with some saved samples. https://www.whiskybase.com/whiskies/whisky/5622/brora-1972-dl-brorageddon 93.93p https://www.whiskybase.com/whiskies/whisky/15343/caol-ila-15-year-old 93.98p https://www.whiskybase.com/whiskies/whisky/1215/talisker-20-year-old-1981 93.84p Result Talisker 1981 20 year - 95 points Caol Ila 15 year Mangers dram sherry - 94.5 points Brorageddon 94 points (perhaps 93.5 is about right) Basically they at all excellent. See https://www.whiskybase.com/contribute/group/73/topic/16768/the-head-to-head-whisky-thread-for-tastings-h2h?page=3
Bottle # 3660 sold empty at ebay.
Excellent. A good little slap, however, not at the level of my best tastings, at least in the style of what I prefer because it must be admitted that it is terribly well done. On the nose, everything is melted to perfection. Peat, spices, dried fruits. The 62 ° are not felt. On the palate, the alcohol is perfectly integrated, the peat takes over slightly (but I have become quite sensitive to it) at the start before giving way to the sweet spices (cinnamon, nutmeg) and dried fruits. The ash accompanies us throughout and is what predominates in the finish. he is incredibly long
Perfect mix of sherry and robust dram
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
92 |
Perfect mix of sweet wood and robust salty dram |
| Вкус |
93 |
Open barbecue, with salt and smoke. And BBQ sauce at finish on top. Delicious |
| Финиш |
91 |
Very long, with persistent sweetness |
Nose: Powerful and elegant Shirley, cherries, cherries, lemon, acidity make it still very vibrant. It's still rich outside of Shirley, minerals, earth, spices, toasted oak bars, chocolate syrup. The expressiveness is a bit lost (but it may be a problem with the body condition), the balance is perfect, and the aromas come and go. I added three drops of water to 15ml of wine, which released more fruit, orange, plum, and anger. It's a pity that I can't find too many Taliskers. Drink: The taste is very special, it is sticky and oily, and then the taste molecules spread out in the mouth. The aroma of sauce, chocolate, fresh sherry, the end rhyme is very long, cherries, sour strawberries, mulberries, puree, and continue to make you salivate. Overall: The smell of this berry fruit reminds me of Longmorn in 1965, but it is more complex, more exciting, and more showy. After drinking 60's Clynelish and 50's Highlang park, I still want to say that, this special taste can be described as amazing. It's like acting in your mouth. Very good experience, I still hope to drink this bottle in a better condition.
A powerful sherry and a high degree, but this Talisker interacts well with them. Light salty sea smoke, earthy peat, expensive pipe tobacco, old leather, chocolate with prunes and pepper. Sea water with honey and citrus peel, spices. An elegant combination of old sherry and talisker cask sea might. 24-24-23-23
нос 95 · вкус 94 · финиш 93
нос 91 · вкус 93 · финиш 93
And so we arrive at dessert. A beautiful, old, dirty sherry with a hint of smoke in the background. ???? Dark chocolate with toffee and hazelnut, blackberry and blackcurrant jam, sea salt, the atmosphere of an old cellar, a hint of mold, espresso. Yum. 95 points!
нос 94 · вкус 95 · финиш 95
This is the famous 100% (?) sherry matured Talisker, with the peat, the pepper and the sherry well married together. A most satisfying Talisker. A pleasure to drink.
Power in the nose and power on the palate, all what you loves at Talisker is united here. Jim Murray says: Miss this and your life will be incomplete, i agree.
нос 94 · вкус 92 · финиш 94
When it came out pricewise, this was a bargain.
нос 95 · вкус 96 · финиш 94
нос 92 · вкус 92 · финиш 91
One heck of a Talisker, and whisky for that matter. Full on nose, sherry, fruits, damp wood, very subtle peat and some struck matches. No off notes what so ever just that hint of matches that complement the whisky in a good way. Salty edge to it, not overly complex but very very nice! Pallet is an explosion, drying in the mouth because of the alcohol blast. But you still taste the sherry, the peat and all the rest of the goodies altho the peat is very subtle here also. Very thick and oily, like cream almost. Makes any other whisky you taste after it feel watery and thin. This is how a whisky should feel. Maybe a tad bitter in the end but still all good. No typical Talisker pepper for me, quite smooth in feel and a little to drinkable. Dangerously drinkable at 62% abv. Finish is one of the longest out there. Goes on and on and on.....and on and... 5 minutes later, yupp, still there! Is it worth 1400-1900€? Not in a million years, prices today are insane. Is it one of the best whiskies on the planet? In my mind, yes, without a doubt. Bravo Talisker!!
Sherry Talisker, there is a lot of sherry, the base is quite tightly packed with a barrel, but in development it still makes way for itself, and it is very dense and rich, deep, interesting.
Simply one of the best Whiskies available!
нос 90 · вкус 91 · финиш 90
One of the best Talisker I and so far. Slightly more powerful then Talisker 1977.
N: an absolute sherry bomb, sweet aromas, somewhat maritime, a nice change. G: maritime saltiness, powerful without burning, sweetish strength, sherry aromas, woody but pleasant. A: It opens up, smoky, sherry sweetness, saltiness, somewhat dry, but pleasant. Very good.
Legendary whisky! Jim Murray wrote in his whisky bible: "I have been tasting Talisker for 28 Years. This is the best bottling ever. Miss this and your life will be incomplete"
from the nose to the finish come and go the flavors mix arbitrarily and excite in every mating This whisky reinvents itself with every sip 95 out of 100 points yes! I'm in heaven ..wow ranking: 1.Nase, 1. Mouth, 1. Reminder
A very powerful Peaty Sherry, but not super complex. For sure, we take a mouthful. But, the addition of water betrays him! This 62% gives it the power needed to stand out, and they are needed! Without that, it becomes really consensual. I ask to taste other Talisker bottled to this degree. Nevertheless, it is an excellent traffic jam, which will become, or is already mythical elsewhere. It's rich, very well balanced, very well integrated. The Sherry did not eat the distillate.
WITH WATER. The nose softens considerably, the palate opens up and is much softer now on coffee, bitter chocolate, leather & tobaccoa. It is also fruity,including a little orange. Taking this down to around 50% and that is where I found it to be most enjoyable on coffee, chocolate, still stewed prunes and figs. Lovely with the right amount of water. I had heard alot about this Talisker and the hype surrounding it. Jim Murray says " miss this and your life will be incomplete". I would not go that far but it is an excellent whisky. I am not a sherry head and found it best with water added and I have to say it was hard to fault. The palate neat is an experience that I have not had for a long time. It was a sort of "bloody hell, god almighty moment" as if a whisky grenade had been thrown into my mouth, "kappow". The nose is fantastic, one of the best.
Perfect Peaty sherry combo. Alcohol is integrated so well. Damn good. White pepper. Meat. A lot of peat. Very long and clean finish. A bit of sulfur yet not disturbing. Oranges too. Salted, maritime. Excellent, magical dram.
93 Nose: A wonderful sherry nose! Bomb! Leather, sea pebbles, prunes, strong tea. Taste: oh-th-th ... The fortress gives its own, but it is excellent! Enveloping, warm, telny. Raisins, dried plums, balsamic vinegar, anesthesia. Aftertaste: very long, It will take a long time to pick out the teeth.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
92 |
Soot, dry, spice-heavy Oloroso sherry, wood fire smoke, salty sea air with a hint of washed-up seaweed, longer hand-warmed, the yellow fruitiness of the Talisker comes to light even under the dark sherry notes, mineral dust, floral notes from ripened peat |
| Вкус |
93 |
even the smallest droplet of mouth-filling explosive preparation on the tongue, a little bit of alcohol on the tongue - notes of pepper and chilli intensify this feeling a little initially deep dark red Oloroso - spicy tannin, then an intense soot note comes to the fore - here, too, the degraded smoke is filled with flower aromas, tar and magic |
| Финиш |
94 |
dark chocolate, oak wall unit, orange oil, delicious soot, sexy notes of bitumen, endlessly long finish |
It sends heavy, the cavalry at full gallop. Peaty, smoky, chocolatey, fruity. The gunpowder explodes all that in the mouth to cover everything with a veil of intense pleasure. We find the spices (pepper, ...) and the angular side of Talisker but also bitter orange zest. The attack is frank, the finish is silky. A velvet hand of an iron glove ;)
Burning, powerful, iodine and sea salt give way to thick tones of sherry, light smoke, as if someone left a hot blowtorch on the leg of an old oak antique chair during the restoration process. And so, this oak got a little burnt. Old leather and chocolate, dry tobacco leaf, dried wild berries on the palate. This is amazing!
нос 93 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
нос 91 · вкус 91 · финиш 90
Tasted on Fri 25th Nov 2022 as part of an East Coast Whisky ‘Ultimate Talisker’ 10-dram vertical (https://www.eastcoastwhisky.com). Colour: Deep copper gold.
нос 92 · вкус 94 · финиш 94
One year after opening, half of the water lines are still strong.
What to say ... it's great, grandiose. And to say that I appreciate only moderately sherry! Alcohol perfectly integrated, harmony between the sea side and sherry. A perfect balance. Sad to finish my sample, happy to have been able to taste that!
I am not usually a fan of Talisker. Here, I must admit that it is very successful, even if I find the nose a little behind the mouth or the final.
22 23 23 23 91 unmatched sherry release, very good, but Talisker is not only the sherry, which is here the most ....
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
91 |
Rich phenolic sherry, very creamy and buttery, huge smoke, classic peppery smoke of Talisker, a tad oaky, some paint, roasted nuts, dried fruits, salted caramel. Rather dirty and complex, some sulfur but not a big deal. |
| Вкус |
89 |
Rich and sulphurous, huge smoke, salty and minty sherry, full-bodied, sour and refreshing, leather, plums, alcohol is not too hot, but 62% is not a joke. |
| Финиш |
91 |
Long, huge smoke, dry sherry, a lot of dried fruits, Turkish delights. |
нос 93 · вкус 95 · финиш 94
Smell ---------------------- 93 taste--------------------93 End rhyme--------------------93
I recently had the standard 30. This one is a different house number, perhaps because of the cask strength and the old times. 91-100 – Whisky heaven, best stuff
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
94 |
Appears sublime, elegant and well aged. Sulfur? Maybe a little, but I think it fits well. Slightly peat, slightly woody, slightly earthy, slightly nutty. Big cinema, big class. Not particularly special in any way, but just very, very well done. |
| Вкус |
90 |
... And then unfortunately it can no longer keep up in the mouth. Strong, wood. |
| Финиш |
94 |
Salivation, so it certainly stimulates. The general notes can also be found here, and they stay for a long time. Slightly nutty. |
Takes a lot of time, tolerates water well but adding more is not absolutely necessary despite the 62%.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос |
92 |
Starts out maritime and mineral with iodine, salt, sea, sulphur and fleeting notes of car paint. Over time the sulphur note diminishes, but the maritime notes remain. Added to this are citrus fruits, yellow fruits, herbs (mint), grasses. Resinous, slightly sweet with a hint of honey, toffee, vanilla, a little leather, spices. |
| Вкус |
92 |
Initially, the taste also has a hint of sulphur, sweet and smoky, slightly mineral and maritime. Citrus fruits, yellow fruit notes, followed by notes of tea, a hint of honey and wax, a little leather and some coffee, salt and a little pepper. Soft despite the 62%, the alcohol is very well integrated. The whisky is subtle and complex at the same time. |
| Финиш |
91 |
slightly sweet, a little mineral and maritime, a little tea, a little floral, a little herbal. Finally with a little pepper, smoke, ash, salt and a hint of leather. Long and pleasant aftertaste. |
нос 91 · вкус 90 · финиш 90
нос 88 · вкус 90 · финиш 90
Perfection of a Talisker...Simply amazingly intense, heavily sherried Talisker that obviously went into the cask at higher percentage of alcohol than the standard 63,5%. The sherry has integrated perfectly, and is so intense, it offers plenty of fruit entangled with the Talisker's smoke and coastal notes. One of the best whiskies out there. Perhaps different bottlings offer different things, but mine had no sulphur at all.
With the best I had in my glass. Super round in taste. Nice pepper with a great integrated sherry. Try it on an epic evening!
Quite a large rubbery note, both on the nose and palate for me. Holding it to 90 and curious why no one else really mentions this, maybe my sample was near the end of the bottle or something
Candied fruits, toffee, iodine, stewed plums, orange, great sherry and peat integration but the slight leather notes prevent me from rating it higher.
Really do not get the high ratings to this talisker, it is sulphury (at least not extreme), very subtle and spicy. Tried it with different levels of water, maybe it is not a good swimmer... anyhow a 2cl sample is enough for me.
нос 94 · вкус 94 · финиш 93